Step One: Cut your losses.
It’s time to give up on the following players (if you haven’t already)**
C: Jason Kendall — You can do better. He may rank fourth in steals among catchers (with 3), but he’s tied for 37th in home runs (with 1) and his .257 AVG / .683 OPS are nothing to get excited about. If you really, truly believe he’s the best catcher available (and he’s not) then just let your catching spot sit empty and carry a deeper bench.
1B: Paul Konerko and Ryan Garko: They don’t crack the top-25 first basemen in Yahoo’s season rankings. Konerko doesn’t even crack the top-50 first basemen in ESPN’s rankings. Why are they on your teams?! Konerko is having his second sub-par season in a row, and is now hurt. Garko just isn’t there yet.
2B: Rickie Weeks — His batting average was already killing your ratios before he hurt his knee. He’s about to come off the DL, and if you have to drop someone to make room for him, just drop him. If his speed is compromised at all by the injury, he’ll be a complete waste of a roster spot. There should be plenty of b-level speed available on the waiver wire.
3B: Casey Blake — There are just too many good third basemen to carry Blake. If/when he heats up, go get him. But until then, his .254 AVG, 6 HR and 1 SB don’t even make him a top-20 third baseman.
SS: Julio Lugo — Shortstop is really not so shallow a position, nor are steals so hard to come by, that Lugo’s presence can be justified in a fantasy lineup. Not even if you’re a Sox fan.
OF: Delmon Young — The Twins are clearly tiring of Young’s lack of power (1 HR!) and patience (.693 OPS), and you should be too. Fortunately, you can drop him without consequence.
SP: Max Scherzer — I was prepared to love him like a cuter, brown-and-blue eyed Tim Lincecum. He’s back in the minors, so love will have to wait ’til next summer (or ’til Randy Johnson’s back gives out).
RP: Rafael Soriano – He’s on the DL for the second time this season, his elbow hurts, Mike Gonzalez is about to come off the DL… if and when Soriano returns, it will most likely be into an awful closer-by-committee situation. It’s not worth the stress.
**All of the players above are on the rosters of one or more teams in my various fantasy baseball leagues — the deepest of which has 12 teams.